The Best Ice Cream Spots Around Cincinnati You Need to Try (2026 Guide)

Nothing says summer in Cincinnati quite like grabbing an ice cream cone on a warm evening. Whether you're craving a classic scoop, handcrafted gelato, frozen custard, or an old-fashioned ice cream parlor experience, Greater Cincinnati has no shortage of incredible places to satisfy your sweet tooth.

From Cincinnati institutions that have been serving families for generations to newer artisan shops creating unique flavors, here are some of the best ice cream spots around Cincinnati.

1. Graeter's Ice Cream

You simply can't talk about Cincinnati ice cream without mentioning Graeter's. Founded in 1870, it's one of the city's most recognizable brands and famous for its French Pot ice cream, made in small batches with massive chunks of gourmet chocolate.

Must-Try Flavors:

• Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip
• Mint Chocolate Chip
• Buckeye Blitz
• Madagascar Vanilla Bean

With locations throughout Greater Cincinnati, it's an easy stop no matter where you are. Even if you've lived here your whole life, a trip to Graeter's never gets old. It's consistently recognized as one of Cincinnati's signature foods.

2. Aglamesis Brothers

Walking into Aglamesis Brothers feels like stepping back in time. The historic soda fountain, vintage décor, and handcrafted desserts make it one of Cincinnati's most unique ice cream experiences.

Beyond the incredible ice cream, don't miss:

• Homemade sundaes
• Banana splits
• Handcrafted chocolates
• Classic soda fountain treats

It's the perfect place for date night, family outings, or anyone looking for a little nostalgia. Many locals consider it one of Cincinnati's best-kept traditions.

3. Dojo Gelato

Located inside Findlay Market, Dojo Gelato has earned a loyal following for its authentic Italian-style gelato made with fresh ingredients.

Expect creative seasonal flavors alongside favorites like:

• Pistachio
• Salted Caramel
• Espresso
• Fresh Fruit Sorbets

It's the perfect excuse to spend a morning exploring Findlay Market before treating yourself to dessert.

4. Hello Honey

One of Cincinnati's newer favorites, Hello Honey specializes in small-batch handcrafted ice cream with inventive seasonal flavors.

Depending on when you visit, you might find:

• Brown Butter Pecan
• Lemon Blueberry
• Strawberry Shortcake
• Honey Lavender
• Cookie Butter

Their downtown and Oakley locations have quickly become popular destinations during the warmer months.

5. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

Originally founded in Ohio, Jeni's has become nationally recognized for its chef-inspired flavors and premium ingredients.

Popular choices include:

• Brambleberry Crisp
• Gooey Butter Cake
• Brown Butter Almond Brittle
• Darkest Chocolate

If you enjoy adventurous flavors, Jeni's is always worth the visit. It continues to receive national recognition from chefs and food critics alike.

6. Gold Spoon Creamery

Located in Blue Ash, Gold Spoon Creamery combines premium ice cream with specialty coffee in a cozy neighborhood setting.

It's a great stop if you're looking for:

• Small-batch ice cream
• Specialty espresso drinks
• Seasonal creations
• Relaxed atmosphere

7. United Dairy Farmers (UDF)

Sometimes the classics are classics for a reason.

Founded right here in Cincinnati, UDF has been serving homemade-style ice cream for generations. While many know them as neighborhood convenience stores, locals know they're also home to excellent milkshakes, sundaes, and hand-dipped cones.

Their homemade ice cream remains a Cincinnati tradition that's perfect for a quick summer stop.

8. Mount Healthy Dairy Bar

If you're searching for classic soft serve, Mount Healthy Dairy Bar is a longtime local favorite.

Known for:

• Huge portions
• Affordable prices
• Homemade-style soft serve
• Old-school neighborhood feel

It's one of those places locals have been visiting for decades.

9. Pendleton Parlor

Located in the Pendleton neighborhood just north of downtown, Pendleton Parlor is known for combining handcrafted ice cream with edible cookie dough.

It's a fun stop if you're looking for:

• Ice cream flights
• Cookie dough creations
• Creative seasonal specials
• A unique dessert experience

10. Buzzed Bull Creamery

For something a little different, Buzzed Bull Creamery uses liquid nitrogen to make ice cream fresh to order.

You can choose:

• Traditional ice cream
• Dairy-free options
• Alcohol-infused ice cream (21+)
• Signature specialty creations

Watching your dessert being made is half the fun.

Local Favorites Worth the Drive

If you're exploring the suburbs, you'll also find great ice cream at:

• Graeter's locations throughout Mason, Montgomery, Hyde Park, Clifton, Kenwood, West Chester, and Northern Kentucky.
• Aglamesis Brothers in Montgomery.
• Gold Spoon Creamery in Blue Ash.
• Dojo Gelato's second location in Northside.

Final Scoop

One of the best parts about living in Cincinnati is the incredible variety of locally owned ice cream shops. Whether you're introducing visitors to Graeter's famous Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, enjoying a handcrafted sundae at Aglamesis Brothers, or trying inventive seasonal flavors at Hello Honey, there's no shortage of places to cool off this summer.

The hardest part isn't finding great ice cream, it's deciding which spot to visit first.

Did we miss your favorite Cincinnati ice cream shop? Let us know, we're always looking for another excuse to grab a scoop!

👉 Looking for more Cincinnati favorites? Check out 10 Places Locals Love but Visitors Usually Miss

If you’re thinking about buying, selling, investing, or relocating, whether now or in the next 6–12 months, we’d love to be a resource for you.